How to ask really useful questions
These days most of us have 'opportunities' in our work to
influence people. That is, in many of our positions we don't
have direct authority, so we can't order things to happen, we
need to advocate, convince, persuade and generally, influence
others. This can be quite tough! But there is one incredibly
powerful tool that we all have, that we frequently don't use
or don't use as effectively as we could. That is
the question. Not a simple question, but a
considered question that looks at
enabling forward movement – un-stuck-ness. Could you ask someone
a question that would put them in a position of power? Read
further to find out how!
Think about questions. They are part of communications, but
they are also part of our thinking. The questions we ask come
from our own individual perception of the world in which we
live. New and different questions can help us to change
our perspective. The questions we ask drive the results we see.
They direct our attention. Are you asking questions that focus
your - and others' - attention on the right place? Do you know
the right place? And how would you know if it were the right
place to focus? What would you see and feel?
The power of questions is that they can lead us to failure
or success. The language we use helps to create our reality.
It is important to be aware of this because it can often get
in the way if used without thought. Here is a simple, straightforward
example:
I worked for a manufacturing company that assembled computer
boards with tiny components on them. There were assembly lines
with machine and hand placement stations on them. I was asked
to do an organisational audit of the manufacturing facility.
At that time, we also knew that morale was very low and there
were quality problems with the product.
I started by asking, "What actually happened?" I wanted facts,
not opinions or judgements. I was told that operators were damaging
Work-In-Progress. So, I asked, "Which operators where causing
the damage? Which lines?" I asked questions that would help
me to understand exactly what was happening, rather than jumping
to conclusions or making assumptions (as the managers had).
I wanted to learn what was happening (not why, which leads to
judgements and blame), what was responsible for what we were
seeing.
This helped us to identify the two lines where the problems
were occurring. We could then focus on further questions: What
did these two lines have in common? A new automatic placement
machine which – we ultimately discovered - had been improperly
calibrated. Just think about what would have happened if we
had continued down the line of judgement – asking the wrong
question. The cost to the company would have been high indeed.
Marilee G. Adams has written a book called, "Change Your
Questions, Change Your Life" (see review below) – it is one
of our favourite books. How can you get the best answers without
asking the best questions? In this book she has a lovely map
called The Choice Map. Based on our questions we can choose
to go down the judger path (blame) or we can choose to go down
the learner path (taking responsibility). Judger questions close
down options and look for someone or something to blame. They
keep us in victim mode. Learner questions do the opposite –
they open things up and help us to focus on possibilities.
Another example: There came a time when my team and I and
many others in our function were going to be made redundant
('laid off' in the USA). I had read Dr. Adams' book, so I bought
a copy for each member of my team to read and help them through
this time. I also coached many of my colleagues. I remember
one in particular who kept asking, "What did I do wrong?" (ever
been there?). She kept repeating the question. I asked her what
a more useful question might be. She stopped cold and looked
at me in astonishment, whatever did I mean? We worked on questions
that were useful in these circumstances and choose the Learner
path. Eventually she came up with "What possibilities are there
for me here and outside the organisation?" and "What would I
like to do next?" She felt great relief – she was no longer
stuck and could move forward. She landed a great job in a different
organisation in a very short time (before her notice period
was up). This didn't mean that the situation was easy for her
or for any of us. But if we could ask different questions we
could stop being stuck.
So, here is a list of some of our favourite questions as
food for thought.
- When you’re stuck, a great question is what Nancy Kline
calls an Incisive Question: What if you knew you could?
What would be the first thing you did? (From Time to Think
by Nancy Kline, see review below)
- Other questions for when you are stuck (especially when
dealing with others), What assumptions are you making? How
else can I think about this situation? What is the other
person thinking, feeling, needing, wanting? ( From Change
Your Questions, Change Your Life)
- What Solutions Focus practitioners call the Miracle
Question: If you woke up tomorrow and your problem had disappeared
overnight, only you didn’t know it, how would you know that
it was gone? What would people be doing differently? What
would you be doing differently? And most importantly in
this line of questioning, What Else?
- A follow on from the Miracle Question is what is called
'Scaling': If what you have described is perfect, where
are you now on a scale of 1 to 10? What would it take to
move you up one step?
- Questions on peak performance are very interesting –
ask someone about a time when they saw peak performance
in a particular area (either for themselves or with someone
else) and get them to tell you a story about it. Explore
with great curiosity and a beginner's mind (that means,
no assumptions). You can then help people to build upon
existing strengths.
- What is working?
- How could I get to win/win?
- What can I learn from this?
- What are my choices?
- What am I responsible for?
- What else is possible?
- When we are working in organisations, a particularly
useful question is : Who is the client for Change?
- What is changing? What will be different because of
the change? Who's going to loose what? (Bridges - see link
below)
- Who is going to gain what?
There is an entire field of strength-based, positive methods
for change which is based on the idea that the questions we
ask are key to developing (and co-creating) a new future.
If you are interested to find out more, contact us at
tricia@lasadev.com
or visit our website for links and books related to Appreciative
Inquiry and Solutions Focus.
You can add to this list of questions and see what you come
up with – it is great having a list of useful questions in your
hip pocket.